By Hakan Talha Yeşil
The U.S. and Greece officials have raised the issue of Türkiye’s membership in NATO. “If Erdogan doesn’t act like an ally, he shouldn’t enjoy the benefits of NATO”. U.S. Senator Rick Scott posted this thesis on his X account describing Ankara as a threat to American interests.
The European Union has joined criticism. The EU leadership recognized the agreement null and void and accused Ankara of its policy. Here the government and the opposition have joined forces due to massive pressure from the West.
Türkiye’s foreign policy will never be controlled from Brussels or Washington, let alone Athens or Tel Aviv. They try using Türkiye’s NATO membership as an extortion point. In actual fact it is NATO who really need Türkiye, not the other way.
Türkiye Libya Maritime Borders Agreement
On October 20, Libya’s eastern-based House of Representatives approved a maritime boundary agreement with Türkiye, following the deal’s earlier approval by the Tripoli-based High Council of State in 2019.
The agreement is aimed at further developing bilateral relations between Libya and Türkiye, and will also strengthen the energy security of both countries.
Türkiye plays a major role in Libya’s political and military affairs. Ankara has acted as a mediator between the parties since the beginning of the internal conflict in Libya. Over the past few years, a major breakthrough has been achieved in this regard.
NATO Unites Against Türkiye
The agreement was met with immediate criticism from most NATO member states and their partners. U.S. State Department described the original Türkiye–Libya agreement as unhelpful and provocative.
U.S. Senator Rick Scott was very sarcastic in his X account. “This is another illegal and thuggish move by Erdogan. It disrespects the United States because it directly threatens the interests of America and our friend and ally, Greece. If Erdogan won’t act like an ally, he shouldn’t enjoy the benefits of NATO,” he said.
Scott is known for his criticism of Türkiye, in particular, he openly supported the imposition of sanctions in 2019. Most congressmen, both Democrats and Republicans, also share this position.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President António Costa also voiced strong criticism of Türkiye, declaring the agreement null and void and stating that the European Union would not recognize it, either legally or politically.
Greece and Israel Joined the Threats
Southern Cyprus, Greece and Israel have shown particular hostility towards Türkiye. Athens rejected the move and said it would take all appropriate measures to undermine its implementation. Israel has also strongly condemned the deal, aligning itself with Greece and Cyprus.
Moreover, Netanyahu once again mentioned Israel’s readiness for war with Türkiye and stated that under certain circumstances Israel does not intend to avoid this war.
In fact, statements of this kind have been happening for several years and are only getting more aggressive. Unlike Türkiye, Israel enjoys the support of the U.S. at all costs: Washington is ready to support any actions of Tel Aviv, including genocide and incitement of interstate conflict.
Aligned Reaction from Türkiye
First of all, why should the U.S. or Greece or the EU or any other state decide for Türkiye what agreements it can conclude? Türkiye’s bilateral relations with any state are a matter exclusively for Türkiye and a particular State.
In these circumstances, even rival politicians and parties have come out with a united front. Hurriyet reported that both the government and opposition parties criticized the West’s position on the agreement with Libya.
Türkiye’s Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan: But both legally and politically, this is an entirely legitimate agreement. There is no need to debate it.
Speaker of the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye (TBMM) Numan Kurtulmuş made the following statement: “Objections and counterclaims raised from the outside regarding this step—taken through the mutual will of two sovereign states—hold no validity for us. Turkey and Libya possess both the will and the capacity to make decisions concerning their own futures.”
AK Party Spokesperson Ömer Çelik stated: “No illegitimate initiative that disregards the rights of Türkiye and brotherly Libya in the Eastern Mediterranean can succeed. The future of the region will be shaped not by impositions, but by fairness and cooperation.”
CHP Chairman Özgür Özel declared: “We reject the statements made by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen targeting the maritime jurisdiction agreement between Türkiye and Libya. Türkiye and Libya are two sovereign states… For us, the rights and interests of Türkiye transcend all our domestic political differences. We will continue to defend our country’s rights and interests on every platform and to stand against your arrogant stance, which has lost all sense of impartiality.”
The Deepening NATO Crisis
After the NATO 2026 summit in Ankara, many tried to show the idyll within the alliance. But for now, it is clear that the threat of war between NATO members arose a couple of months after the end of the summit.
Donald Trump promised a lot to President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. As we can see, all these big promises have remained just words. Moreover, now U.S. congressmen openly call Türkiye a threat to U.S. interests. The fact is that the U.S. and the EU are not at all satisfied with Türkiye’s multi-vector policy.
But it because of that Türkiye had been able to begin its journey into the “Türkiye Yüzyılı”, the Century of Türkiye. Does Türkiye need an alliance that considers it a threat, and which becomes a threat itself? Our government needs to give a balanced response to all the threats.












